April 21, 2023

The priest-penitent privilege laws need to be changed to protect children

As a former pastor and advocate for the protection of children, I strongly believe that the priest-penitent privilege should be re-evaluated in Arizona law. The recent court ruling that upheld the privilege in a sexual abuse case highlights the need for reform in this area. The priest-penitent privilege is an important aspect of religious freedom, allowing individuals to confess their sins to a religious leader without fear of disclosure. However, this privilege should not be used as a shield to protect abusers from prosecution or to allow churches to avoid their responsibility to report abuse. In my opinion, the priest-penitent privilege should be similar to the attorney-client privilege in Arizona law (Ariz. R. Sup. Ct. ER 1.6), which has specific limitations and exceptions. For example, the attorney-client privilege does not apply when a client seeks legal advice to further a crime or fraud, or when disclosure is necessary to prevent harm to others. Similarly, the priest-penitent privilege should not apply in cases where abuse or neglect of a child is suspected or has occurred. This would ensure that clergy members are not able to use their position to facilitate or cover up abuse, and that children are protected from harm. It is time for Arizona legislators to take action and reform the priest-penitent privilege to better protect children from abuse. I urge Arizona Legislators to consider introducing bills to limit the scope of the privilege and to provide exceptions where necessary, in order to ensure that justice is served and children are kept safe. As a former pastor and currently a lobbyist, I believe that protecting children should always be one of our highest priorities, and we must take every step necessary to prevent and punish abuse. I will be advocating for this. Who is with me? #solutionary #epicpolicy https://azcapitoltimes.com/news/2023/04/17/court-protects-church-that-shielded-abuser-whos-protecting-children