December 13, 2023

How bad does the housing shortage impact our healthcare?

I recently read an article on the relationship between housing shortages around the country and healthcare professional shortages. We have both in Arizona. The housing shortage, especially in rural areas, presents a significant challenge for healthcare providers in recruiting and retaining staff, as seen in the case of Memorial Regional Health in Craig, Colorado. Promising job candidates often rescind their acceptances due to the difficulty in finding suitable housing, and those who do accept positions frequently have to settle for suboptimal living situations, such as residing in campers. This shortage encompasses a range of housing types, from low-income rentals to middle- and upper-income single-family homes, and is exacerbated by factors like the influx of urban remote workers and the burgeoning short-term rental market.

This issue extends beyond healthcare, affecting other community employers including schools and businesses. Many rural healthcare providers lack the resources to build employee housing and are thus turning to creative partnerships to find solutions. In Craig, for example, the Memorial Regional Health Board donated land to the Craig Housing Authority, which then used grant funding to build a townhome complex. These homes, reserved in part for healthcare employees, are affordable and come with restrictions to ensure long-term affordability.

The rural housing market is complex and varies regionally, with some areas experiencing significant growth while others see declines or minimal changes. A common problem is the lack of affordable rental properties and starter homes, contributing to a shortage in housing supply. The scarcity of housing impacts the availability of accommodations for the workforce and poses infrastructure challenges.

Rural healthcare providers face numerous hurdles due to this housing shortage, affecting essential roles across various income levels. As housing costs rise, a significant portion of rural households spend more than 30% of their income on housing. Innovative projects are emerging to address these challenges, such as one in rural Oregon that transforms a former hotel into market-rate rentals for healthcare workers and permanent supportive housing for those at risk of homelessness. This project has received positive community response and serves as a model of collaboration to tackle housing needs.

Columbia Pacific, the organization leading the Oregon project, plans to assess the impact of their housing initiative on healthcare recruitment and retention. This example underscores the importance of affordable housing in ensuring a stable workforce in rural healthcare settings. By offering budget-friendly housing options, healthcare providers can attract and retain employees who might otherwise be deterred by the lack of suitable living arrangements.

Solving the rural housing shortage requires collaboration among healthcare providers, community organizations, and government entities. The initiatives in Craig, Colorado, and rural Oregon illustrate successful partnerships addressing this issue. Exploring alternative housing models, such as modular or cooperative housing, could provide additional solutions to alleviate housing scarcity.

The housing shortage in rural areas is a critical issue impacting the recruitment and retention of healthcare professionals. Addressing this challenge through innovative solutions and partnerships is essential for maintaining a stable and effective healthcare workforce in these communities. Let’s see if any Arizona legislators look into this and find a solution.